Dr. KinyasHair Clinic · IstanbulLibrary ←
Science and Research Centre / Graft Preparation and Survival

Dr. Kinyas Hair Clinic · Science and Research Centre

Graft Storage Solutions: More Than a Product Name

The interval between harvesting and implantation is a chain of preservation. Solution, time, temperature and handling act together. One fluid’s name cannot explain the quality of that entire chain.

First identify the question being answered

Storage studies may measure different outcomes. Cell staining, cell outgrowth in culture, early shedding and later hair production are distinct endpoints. A claim of good viability must identify the test used. [1]

A follicle contains multiple cellular and tissue components. A single laboratory finding does not equal the cosmetic outcome of the entire transplant. Long-term patient outcomes need separate follow-up. [1] (endpoint interpretation framework)

Interpreting the 2023 clinical comparison

Zhou and colleagues compared a specific supplemented HTK formula with Ringer’s solution in 240 patients. The accessible abstract reported differences in some early shedding measures but no difference in final survival. The proportion of patients who shed is not the percentage of grafts lost. [3]

Results from one mixture cannot establish each component’s separate effect or superiority to all fluids. Without full methods, subgroups should not become definitive individual recommendations. [3]

Why laboratory temperatures are not operative instructions

Nerkar’s study assessed cell outgrowth from 60 follicles from three volunteers under different media and temperatures. That is not 60 patients or long-term transplant outcomes. Culture conditions differ from hourly intraoperative holding. [4]

Cell growth in such an experiment cannot establish one storage temperature for all clinical grafts. The study purpose, medium and measurement time must be interpreted together. [4]

Where does expert guidance apply?

The 2023 consensus discusses extracellular media and intracellular preservation media considered under specific conditions. Cooling recommendations do not mean strong clinical trials prove routine cooling superior in every circumstance. [1]

Time, composition and temperature need joint consideration. This text neither declares every follicle dead after a fixed time nor mandates one temperature for all fluids and procedures. Local protocols need their own justification. [1]

What should quality records show?

Records can include harvest/implantation times, exact medium and composition, and measured conditions. A room or device setting alone may not establish actual graft conditions. This recording framework is a clinical quality recommendation.

Drying, crushing and loading trauma also affect preservation. A more expensive product cannot guarantee compensation for every injury. Outcomes require appropriate measurement and follow-up, not marketing descriptions. [1]

A practical patient question

Alongside asking for the best fluid, ask how your grafts are protected throughout surgery and how conditions are monitored. An explanation of the process is more useful than a brand alone. Study results cannot substitute for a clinic’s own measured outcomes. [1] (consultation recommendation)

The clinic’s storage approach should be assessed together with its actual fluid and conditions. Once documented, similarities and differences from study conditions should be considered separately.

References and access limitations

This article is based on a targeted review of sources; it is not an original systematic review.

  1. Vañó-Galván S et al. An international expert consensus statement focusing on pre and post hair transplantation care. 2023. DOI: 10.1080/09546634.2023.2232065. PMID: 37477225.

    Expert consensus. Assessment limited to accessible main text; Table 3 was not fully assessed. DUCRAY/Pierre Fabre support; not an independent randomised superiority trial.

  2. Mysore V et al. Hair Transplant Practice Guidelines. J Cutan Aesthet Surg. 2021;14:265–284. DOI: 10.4103/JCAS.JCAS_104_20.

    Expert practice guidance. Includes expert opinion where evidence is lacking; not presented as Turkish legislation or a universal standard of care.

  3. Zhou Y et al. Evaluation of a Novel Graft-Holding Solution in Hair Transplantation: A Randomized Controlled Clinical Study. Dermatol Surg. 2023;49:675–681. DOI: 10.1097/DSS.0000000000003799. PMID: 37036372.

    Randomised study of 240 patients; abstract access. HTK-AD versus Ringer; early shedding distinguished from final survival. Full methods, allocation and subgroups were not read.

  4. Nerkar GM et al. An In vitro Study Comparing the Survival of Hair Follicles in Various Storage Media at Different Temperatures. 2025;17:121–127. DOI: 10.4103/ijt.ijt_41_23. PMID: 41306835.

    Three volunteers/60 follicles; in vitro study, abstract access. Cell-outgrowth endpoint, not long-term clinical hair growth. No inference that all surgical grafts should be stored at 37°C; full text and supplements were not read.

← Back to section
WhatsApp
DR. KINYAS HAIR CLINIC

Quick Contact

Leave your details and we will contact you through your preferred channel.

How should we contact you?

Dr. Kinyas Hair Clinic uses your details to respond to your request and contact you.