Dr. KinyasHair Clinic · IstanbulLibrary ←
Science and Research Centre / FUE Biomechanics

Dr. Kinyas Hair Clinic · Science and Research Centre

FUE Transection: Reading a Damage Rate Correctly

A very low transection claim is meaningful only when what is counted and how are explained. Cutting follicular structures is an important quality indicator, but cannot describe the entire transplant outcome.

Is cutting a shaft the same as damaging a follicle?

Transection describes partial or complete cutting of follicular structures during surgical harvesting. Everyday shaft cutting or postoperative shedding are different events. Seeing a shaft on a crust does not reveal the intraoperative transection rate. [1], [2]

A graft can carry several follicles. Damage to part of a unit must be distinguished from loss of its entire contents. The level and extent of damage may affect biological outcomes; visible cutting cannot establish a definitive survival/death count for every follicle. [1]

Why does the denominator change the result?

Imagine 100 extracted grafts containing 200 follicles in total. If ten grafts each contain one damaged follicle, the rate is 10/100 for damaged grafts but 10/200 for damaged follicles. These conceptual numbers illustrate different percentages; they are not clinical rates.

Reports should specify whether the denominator is attempted harvests, successfully extracted grafts or examined follicles. Excluding failed attempts or buried grafts can make results look better. Direct comparisons between differently defined rates are misleading. [1], [2] (counting framework: editorial methods recommendation)

Why is low transection insufficient on its own?

Crushing, stripping surrounding tissue, excessive traction or drying may occur without transection. Microscopic appearance, handling conditions and later growth therefore require joint assessment. Visible integrity alone does not demonstrate that every cell remains viable. [1], [2]

Recipient-site implantation and healing also influence the final result. Turning an extraction-stage percentage directly into an expected growth percentage skips other stages. Patient satisfaction and follicle counts are also different measurements.

What should research report?

Reports should describe punch diameter and geometry, movement, hair/skin characteristics, assessment methods and sampling. Examining many grafts cannot replace having enough patients; units from one person are not wholly independent observations. [1], [2] (research assessment framework)

Sampling only a good-looking region may not represent the whole donor. Repeated quality checks can help reassess settings when damage clusters or hair direction changes. This page gives no mandatory sample count or universal acceptance threshold. [2]

What report should a patient request?

Ask how planned, extracted and implanted grafts are distinguished, and how any damage measure is defined. One hair is not one graft. Counts at different stages and follow-up photographs can form an understandable record. [1], [2] (record-keeping recommendation)

Look for explanations of measurement scope and limits rather than claims of no damage or certain results from a low rate. A low rate can matter, but individual outcomes also depend on donor selection, preservation, implantation and follow-up. This article reports no measured clinic rate.

References and access limitations

This article is based on a targeted review of sources; it is not an original systematic review.

  1. Garg AK, Garg S. Donor Harvesting: Follicular Unit Excision. J Cutan Aesthet Surg. 2018;11:195–201. DOI: 10.4103/JCAS.JCAS_123_18. PMID: 30886473.

    Technical narrative review, not a randomised device-superiority trial. Its accounts of buried-graft frequency and forceps counts in manual/motorised methods are internally inconsistent; those statements were not converted into recommendations.

  2. ISHRS FUE Advancement Committee. FUE Clinical Practice Guidelines. 15 July 2019.

    Professional expert guidance, not a universal prescription for diameter, depth or speed across all devices.

← Back to section
WhatsApp
DR. KINYAS HAIR CLINIC

Quick Contact

Leave your details and we will contact you through your preferred channel.

How should we contact you?

Dr. Kinyas Hair Clinic uses your details to respond to your request and contact you.